The long-awaited battle between [Real Madrid](https://apitofinal.pt/internacional/cristiano-ronaldo-e-o-recorde-de-golos-a-lista-dos-melhores-artilheiros-em-discussao/) and [Manchester City](https://apitofinal.pt/internacional/valverde-do-real-madrid-vive-a-melhor-noite-da-sua-carreira/) in the [UEFA Champions League](https://apitofinal.pt/internacional/arbeloa-pondera-alteracao-tatica-crucial-para-real-madrid-frente-ao-manchester-city/) ended with a clear advantage for the Merengues, who inflicted a resounding 3-0 defeat on the English side at the [Santiago Bernabéu Stadium](https://apitofinal.pt/internacional/capitao-do-real-madrid-brilha-com-hat-trick-espetacular-contra-o-man-city/). City manager Pep Guardiola can breathe a sigh of relief that there are no manager rankings, as his strategy in the first leg of the Round of 16 was a complete disaster that left fans in shock.
Facing a depleted Real Madrid, without stars Kylian Mbappé, Jude Bellingham, Eder Militao, and Rodrygo, City seemed on course for an easy victory but found themselves in trouble by halftime. Federico Valverde was the star of the night, scoring an impressive hat-trick before the break, leaving Guardiola’s team without an answer.
Valverde’s performance was largely at the expense of Nico O’Reilly, who, despite showing quality in midfield, was completely overwhelmed when relegated to the left-back position, leaving the defense exposed. Meanwhile, Savinho, who started the game, had a lackluster performance, while Phil Foden and Rayan Cherki watched from the bench.
If Manchester City fails to turn the situation around in their next home game, the criticism of Guardiola will be relentless, accusing him of being overly clever at crucial moments.
The player ratings reveal a picture of the disparity between the two teams.
**Real Madrid Player Ratings:**
– **Thibaut Courtois: 9** — In addition to an assist, he was excellent with the ball at his feet and made a crucial save in the second half.
– **Ferland Mendy: 7** — A solid performance at left-back.
– **Dean Huijsen: 6.5** — Did not make any significant errors.
– **Antonio Rudiger: 8** — A dominant performance in central defense, including a spectacular intervention that prevented a goal from Erling Haaland.
– **Trent Alexander-Arnold: 6.5** — Shone with the ball but was lacking defensively.
– **Federico Valverde: 9.5** — An almost perfect game, with three goals and notable defensive contributions.
– **Thiago Pitarch: 6.5** — Good presence on the pitch but a bit inexperienced in some situations.
– **Aurelien Tchouameni: 7** — Managed the midfield well, committing fouls when necessary.
– **Arda Guler: 7.5** — Continues to evolve and show intensity.
– **Brahim Diaz: 6.5** — Good assist but little more.
– **Vinicius Junior: 6.5** — Earned a penalty but was unable to convert.
**Manchester City Player Ratings:**
– **Gianluigi Donnarumma: 6** — Conceded 4.05 xG and made four saves, but the penalty given away was a mistake.
– **Nico O’Reilly: 4** — Disastrous performance, exposed by Valverde.
– **Marc Guehi: 5** — Struggled to keep up with Real’s attacks.
– **Ruben Dias: 6.5** — Good interventions, but insufficient to avoid defeat.
– **Abdukodir Khusanov: 7** — Showed energy and helped stabilize the team.
– **Rodri: 7** — Not responsible for the defeat, but offered little help to the attack.
– **Savinho: 6** — Substituted at halftime after an ineffective display.
– **Bernardo Silva: 7** — Worked hard in midfield, creating some opportunities.
– **Jeremy Doku: 7.5** — Forced Real to defend, but without conversions.
– **Antoine Semenyo: 6** — Tried, but without success.
– **Erling Haaland: 4.5** — Completely absent, with only 10 touches before being substituted.
The ratings for the substitutes were not remarkable, but the change of Mendy for Fran Garcia at halftime was a worthwhile strategy for Real.
With this defeat, Manchester City faces a colossal challenge in the second leg. Criticism of Guardiola may increase, and the team’s future in the competition is at stake. The pressure is high, and all eyes will be on the team’s response in the next match.
Discover more from Apito Final
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
