Roy Keane suggests alternatives for the manager position at Manchester United.

Roy Keane, one of the most respected and controversial voices in football, has expressed his strong opinion on the future of Manchester United, and the message is clear: Michael Carrick is not the right man to lead the club in the long term. In a deep analysis of the options available to the Red Devils’ management, Keane suggests that figures like Diego Simeone and Luis Enrique should be the focus in the search for a new permanent manager.

Since Ruben Amorim’s departure, Carrick has taken over as interim manager, and under his leadership, Manchester United has shown admirable performance. The 3-1 victory over Aston Villa last Sunday marked the sixth consecutive home win, solidifying the team’s third place in the Premier League, with only eight games remaining this season. The transformation in the club’s environment is undeniable, as the Red Devils have secured seven wins in nine matches under Carrick’s stewardship. However, this impressive streak does not seem to be enough to convince Keane that Carrick is the right choice for the future.

In statements made to Sky Sports, Keane did not hold back criticism and questioned the logic of keeping Carrick in the manager’s position. “There are numerous options available,” he stated. “Are we all here, former players, saying that there are no better options than Michael Carrick? That doesn’t make sense.” His frank stance reveals a desire to see Manchester United return to being a dominant force in football, and he believes the solution lies in established names.

Keane specifically mentioned Simeone, manager of Atlético de Madrid, and Luis Enrique, current coach of Paris Saint-Germain, as viable alternatives. He also referenced Thomas Tuchel, who recently renewed his contract with the England national team until 2028, as one of the best candidates the club should consider. “Get the best. Carrick is not the best option for Manchester United. Simple,” Keane emphasized, showing his determination to see the club make a more informed choice.

Although Carrick has shown competence in his interim role, Keane believes that appointing him to the permanent position would be a mistake. “If they give him the job, good luck to him. And if he manages to do what is needed in the coming years and United wins titles, I will be here admitting that I was wrong. No problem. But I believe there are better options available,” he concluded.

It is clear that the future of Manchester United is at stake, and the decisions made in the coming weeks could define not only the club’s trajectory, but also Carrick’s. With pressure mounting and fan expectations rising, the need for a strong and visionary leader has never been more evident. Keane’s words resonate as a warning: Manchester United must aim high in its search for a new manager.